[1]熊国胜 余光书 林焱斌△ 江小香 王明贺.髓内钉与钢板内固定治疗胫骨远端骨折的Meta分析[J].中国中医骨伤科杂志,2016,24(02):22-28.
 XIONG Guosheng YU Guangshu LIN Yanbin JIANG Xiaoxiang WANG Minghe.Meta-analysis of Intramedullary Nail and Plate Fixation in Treatment of Distal Tibial Fractures[J].Chinese Journal of Traditional Medical Traumatology & Orthopedics,2016,24(02):22-28.
点击复制

髓内钉与钢板内固定治疗胫骨远端骨折的Meta分析
分享到:

《中国中医骨伤科杂志》[ISSN:1005-0205/CN:42-1340/R]

卷:
第24卷
期数:
2016年02期
页码:
22-28
栏目:
临床研究
出版日期:
2016-02-14

文章信息/Info

Title:
Meta-analysis of Intramedullary Nail and Plate Fixation in Treatment of Distal Tibial Fractures
文章编号:
1005-0205(2016)02-0022-07
作者:
熊国胜1 余光书1 林焱斌1△ 江小香2 王明贺2
1.厦门大学附属福州第二医院创伤骨科(福州,350007)
2.福建中医药大学研究生院
△.通信作者 E-mail:Email:812953900@qq.com
Author(s):
XIONG Guosheng1 YU Guangshu1 LIN Yanbin1△ JIANG Xiaoxiang2 WANG Minghe2
1.Department of Traumatic Orthopedics,Fuzhou Second Hospital Affiliated to Xiamen University, Xiamen 350007,Fujian China;
2.Postgraduate School, Fujian University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Fuzhou 350012, China.
关键词:
胫骨远端骨折 髓内钉 钢板 Meta分析
Keywords:
distal tibial fracture intramedullary nail plate Meta-analysis
分类号:
R683.42
文献标志码:
A
摘要:
目的:探讨髓内钉与钢板内固定治疗胫骨远端骨折的疗效差异。方法:运用计算机检索PubMed,Cochrane Library,EMBASE,BIOSIS,Ovid databases,中国知网(CNKI)、维普数据库、万方数据库以及手工检索相关文献。收集1990年1月1日至2015年6月1日国内外公开发表的有关髓内钉与钢板内固定治疗胫骨远端骨折的临床疗效对比随机对照的英文与中文文献。严格评价纳入研究的方法学质量并提取资料,统计软件采用RevMan5.1.0.结果:共纳入13个随机对照实验文献,其中英文文献8篇,中文文献5篇。髓内钉治疗组440例,钢板内固定治疗组409例。根据改良后的Jadad评分标准,有6篇文献为高质量文献,7篇文献为低质量文献。Meta分析结果显示,钢板内固定治疗胫骨下段骨折的手术时间少于髓内钉内固定时间(WMD为-10.39,95%CI为-17.59~-3.19,P=0.005); 骨折愈合时间短于髓内钉内固定时间(WMD为-5.20,95%CI为-4.11~-0.15,P=0.03),AOFAS评分比髓内钉分数更高(WMD为2.08,95%CI为1.52~2.64,P<0.001); 其总的并发症差异无统计学意义(RR为0.75,95%CI为0.47~1.21,P=0.24),但是感染发生率比髓内钉组高(RR为0.59,95%CI为0.36~0.98,P=0.04)。结论:总体而言,髓内钉与钢板内固定各有优缺点,在软组织条件允许的情况下可以优先考虑选择钢板内固定治疗,尤其是应用经皮锁定钢板。
Abstract:
Objective: To explore the efficacy difference between intramedullary nail and plate fixation in treating distal tibial fractures. Methods:Relevant references of intramedullary nail and plate fixation treating distal tibial fractures from January 1,1990 to June 1,2015 were searched through PubMed, Cochrane Library, EMBASE, BIOSIS, Ovid databases, China HowNet(CNKI), VIP database and Wanfang database.The data of the study were strictly evaluated, using RevMan5.1.0 for statistical analysis. Results: 13 randomized control trial references were enrolled,including 8 English references and 5 Chinese references,440 cases in the intramedullary nail group and 409 cases in the plate fixation group. According to the improved Jadad score standard, there are 6 references in high-quality and 7 in low-quality. Meta-analysis showed that the operation time of plate fixation is less than intramedullary nail fixation(WMD=-10.39, 95% CI=-17.59~-3.19,P=0.005).The fracture healing time of plate fixation is shorter than that of intramedullary nail fixation(WMD=-5.20,95% CI=-4.11~-0.15,P= 0.03).The AOFAS score in plate fixation group is higher than that in intramedullary nail fixation group(WMD=2.08,95%CI=1.52 P<0.001).The overall complication has no significant difference in two groups(RR=0.75,95%CI=0.47~1.21,P=0.24), but the infection rate in the plate fixation group is higher than that in the intramedullary nail group(RR=0.59,95%CI=0.36~0.98,P=0.04). Conclusion: There are advantages and disadvantages in intramedullary nail and plate fixation. It prefers to consider plate fixation if the soft tissue permits, especially percutaneous locking plate applications.

参考文献/References:

[1] Ristiniemi J,Luukinen P,Ohtonen P.Surgical treatment of extra-artitular or simple intra-articular distal tibial fractures:external fixation versus intramedullary nailing[J].J Orthop Trauma,2011,25(2):101-105.
[2] Yaligod V,Rudrappa GH,Nagendra S,et al.Minimizing the complications of intramedullary nailing for distal thirdtibial shaft and metaphyseal fractures[J].J Orthop,2014,11(1):10-18.
[3] Vicenti G,Pesce V,Tartaglia N,et al.Micromotion in the fracture healing of closed distal metaphyseal tibialfractures:a multicentre prospective study[J].Injury,2014,45(6):27-35.
[4] Richard RD,Kubiak E,Horwitz DS.Techniques for the surgical treatment of distal tibia fractures[J].Orthop Clin North Am,2014,45(3):295-312.
[5] Katsenis DL,Begkas D,Spiliopoulos G,et al.The results of closed intramedullary nailing for intra-articular distal tibial fractures[J].J Orthop Trauma,2014,28(2):108-113.
[6] Attal R,Maestri V,Doshi HK,et al.The influence of distal locking on the need for fibular plating in intramedullary nailing of distal metaphyseal tibiofibular fractures[J].Bone Joint J,2014,96(3):385-389.
[7] Richard RD,Kubiak E,Horwitz DS.Techniques for the surgical treatment of distal tibia fractures[J].Orthop Clin North Am,2014,45(3):295-312.
[8] Kreder HJ,Hanel DP,Agel J,et al.Indirect reduction and percutaneous fixation versus open reduction and internal fixation for displaced intra-articular fractures of the distal radius:a randomised,controlled trial[J].J Bone Joint Surg Br,2005,87(6):829-836.
[9] Im GI,Tae SK.Distal metaphyseal fractures of tibia:a prospective randomized trial of closed reduction and intramedullary nail versus open reduction and plate and screws fixation[J].J Trauma,2005,59(5):1219-1223.
[10] Yang SW,Tzeng HM,Chou YJ,et al.Treatment of distal tibial metaphyseal fractures:plating versus shortened intramedullary nailing[J].Injury,2006,37(6):531-535.
[11] Guo JJ,Tang N,Yang HL,et al.A prospective,randomised trial comparing closed intramedullary nailing with percutaneous plating in the treatment of distal metaphyseal fractures of the tibia[J].J Bone Joint Surg Br,2010,92(7):984-988.
[12] Vallier HA,Cureton BA,Patterson BM.Randomized,prospective comparison of plate versus intramedullary nail fixation for distal tibia shaft fractures[J].J Orthop Trauma,2011,25(12):736-741.
[13] Vallier HA,Cureton BA,Patterson BM.Factors influencing functional outcomes after distal tibia shaft fractures[J].J Orthop Trauma,2012,26(3):178-183.
[14] Li Y,Liu L,Tang X,et al.Comparison of low,multidirectional locked nailing and plating in the treatment of distal tibial metadiaphyseal fractures[J].Int Orthop,2012,36(7):1457-1462.
[15] Mauffrey C,McGuinness K,Parsons N,et al.A randomised pilot trial of "locking plate" fixation versus intramedullary nailing for extra-articular fractures of the distal tibia[J].J Bone Joint Surg Br,2012,94(5):704-708.
[16] Li Y,Jiang X,Guo Q,et al.Treatment of distal tibial shaft fractures by three different surgical methods:a randomized,prospective study[J].Int Orthop,2014,38(6):1261-1267.
[17] 沈进稳,瞿杭波,童培建,等.骨皮质形态与胫骨下段骨折内固定选择的研究[J].中医正骨,2007,19(10):7-9.
[18] 田文,王富明,黄俭,等.髓内钉、锁定加压钢板内固定术治疗胫骨下段骨折疗效比较[J].山东医药,2013,53(31):53-55.
[19] 黄勇全,刘先明,陈文明,等.髓内钉结合阻挡钉与经皮锁定钢板固定胫骨远侧干骺端骨折的比较[J].实用临床医学,2012,13(11):33-36.
[20] 沈建伟,戚飞成,余华晨.髓内钉与传统钢板螺丝内固定治疗胫骨远端骨折疗效对比分析[J].中国现代医生,2015,53(4):42-44.
[21] 王世坤,史宗新,刘新民,等.髓内钉与锁定钢板内固定治疗胫骨远侧干骺端骨折的比较研究[J].中国骨与关节损伤杂志,2013,28(1):977-978.
[22] Zou J,Zhang W,Zhang CQ.Comparison of minimally invasive percutaneous plate osteosynthesis with open reduction and internal fixation for treatment of extra-articular distal tibia fractures[J].Injury,2013,44(8):1102-1106.
[23] Yang SW,Kuo SM,Chang SJ,et al.Biomechanical comparison of axial load between cannulated locking screws and noncannulated cortical locking screws[J].Orthopedics,2013,36(10):1316-1321.
[24] Encinas-Ullan CA,Fernandez-Fernandez R,Rubio-Suarez JC,et al.Medial versus lateral plating in distal tibial fractures:a prospective study of 40 fractures[J].Rev Esp Cir Ortop Traumatol,2013,57(2):117-122.
[25] Bingol I,Yalcin N,Bicici V,et al.Minimally invasive percutaneous plate osteosynthesis does not increase complication rates in extra-articular distal tibial fractures[J].Open Orthop J,2015,9:73-77.
[26] Bhat R,Wani MM,Rashid S,et al.Minimally invasive percutaneous plate osteosynthesis for closed distal tibial fractures:a consecutive study based on 25 patients[J].Eur J Orthop Surg Traumatol,2015,25(3):563-568.
[27] Chan DS,Nayak AN,Blaisdell G,et al.Effect of distal interlocking screw number and position after intramedullary nailing of distal tibial fractures:a biomechanical study simulating immediate weight-bearing[J].J Orthop Trauma,2015,29(2):98-104.
[28] Salem KH.Unreamed intramedullary nailing in distal tibial fract-ures[J].Int Orthop,2013,37(10):2009-2015.
[29] Stathopoulos I,Karampinas P,Evangelopoulos DS,et al.Radiation-free distal locking of intramedullary nails:evaluation of a new electromagnetic computer-assisted guidance system[J].Injury,2013,44(6):872-875.
[30] Dursun M,Kalkan T,Aytekin MN,et al.Does the magnetic-guided intramedullary nailing technique shorten operation time and radiation exposure?[J].Eur J Orthop Surg Traumatol,2014,24(6):1005-1011.

备注/Memo

备注/Memo:
收稿日期:2015-07-02
更新日期/Last Update: 2016-02-02